Shows like The Polygamist
If you liked The Polygamist, the best matches are Dynasty, Goliath and Painkiller.
The Polygamist thrives on the kind of high-stakes domestic chaos that makes your own family drama look like a quiet afternoon nap. With its nonlinear timeline and obsession with reputation, it is a masterclass in watching a picture-perfect life implode under the weight of secrets.
The following picks lean into that same delicious toxicity. Expect plenty of scandals, questionable life choices, and enough emotional fallout to keep you glued to the screen.
Get picks tuned to your taste Updated
1. Dynasty 2017 · Series
86If you enjoyed the high-stakes social posturing of the wealthy, this soap offers plenty of feuding and family drama.
- Netflix
2. Goliath 2016 · Series
60This legal drama trades marital scandals for courtroom conspiracies, though it keeps the focus on a protagonist facing ruin.
- Amazon Prime Video
3. Painkiller 2023 · Series
53This series shifts from personal family secrets to a broader societal crisis, maintaining a heavy and serious dramatic tone.
- Netflix
4. Tell Me Lies 2022 · Series
81This show captures the same addictive, messy entanglement of relationships that makes the source material so difficult to ignore.
- Hulu
5. 56 Days 2026 · Series
78Like the source, this uses a nonlinear structure to peel back the layers of a complicated and dangerous romance.
- Amazon Prime Video
6. Good Girls 2018 · Series
73If you want more women navigating desperate circumstances and scandalous secrets, this crime drama delivers the same frantic energy.
- Netflix
7. True Detective 2014 · Series
69This shares the nonlinear timeline and the slow unearthing of dark secrets, though it trades soap for police procedural.
- HBO Max
8. Bel-Air 2022 · Series
64This focuses on the friction of wealth and family dynamics, though it leans more into culture clash than scandal.
- Peacock
More lists to explore
Ratings and streaming availability come from TMDB and JustWatch and can change. The notes are written by AI from TMDB data and may occasionally miss.